We recognize the diversity of opinions within the Jewish community on environmental issues. A full fossil fuel screen didn’t reflect a consensus, nor did having no screen at all. Instead, only companies with revenue from oil sands are screened out—an energy production process that’s three times more carbon intensive than conventional oil, depletes freshwater, and creates toxic waste. This allows the Jewish community to have a voice in many other fossil fuel companies and still have an environmental screen that screens out the worst actors. 

Ultimately, we prefer constructive engagement over exclusion. By holding shares in fossil fuel companies, we can vote on proposals for improved efficiency in energy production and we can engage with them on other Jewish communal interests, such as promoting antisemitism education in their workplaces.